3 and 5 for me...if you want to retain a little similarity to your old logo then 3 - but i like th big 'G'...
Jason
· 4 years ago
Your designer buddy is quite good. They all look nice. However, some work for me and others don't. 1. Too many bubbles, like there is a mass of folks talking and hard to concentrate on anything in particular. 2. Looks cool, but I don't see what it's supposed to represent. 3. The G is neat, is it for "guy" though? 4. This one I like, less comment bubbles, but still in a cool pattern. 5. I like the implied bubble, but a little thin for my tastes. 6. A pattern of 5s. Eh. 7. I like this one as well. The heads talking to each other.
So I like 4 & 7, and I'm leaning towards 7.
johnmoore (from Brand Autopsy)
· 4 years ago
My thin-slice approach likes Option Four. Why? Well, it showcases the interdependence that must exist for a collection of people to become a community.
Jim Allen
· 4 years ago
First, I concur: your designer buddy is very good. These are all very interesting designs.
Second, #3 is the one. I like that it incorporates the "C" and "G" of Community Guy as well as keeps the talk-balloon meme that implies conversation and, thus, community.
#1 is a bit much methinks. #2 makes me think of something photo-related. #4 interesting but not enoughso #5 makes me think something's missing. #6 & #7 nice to look at but a little too abstract
So, it's #3, definitely. Nice meme that really markets YOU and what you're talking about.
Rob Cottingham
· 4 years ago
For me, number 7 jumped ahead of the pack. I can see an implied "G" in that tasty little logo, and it conveys ideas of integration, diversity and the ol' yin-'n'-yang.
pall
· 4 years ago
1. number 6 is something i'd look at longer than any of the others.
Lee
· 4 years ago
Thanks for the differentiation Jake! My votes are for 4 and 6, with 1 being a close third... If I had to choose 1- it would be 6...
Jake
· 4 years ago
Thanks for the help all! I'm reading your feedback tonight and will hopefully be able to choose this week.
All Comments
1. Too many bubbles, like there is a mass of folks talking and hard to concentrate on anything in particular.
2. Looks cool, but I don't see what it's supposed to represent.
3. The G is neat, is it for "guy" though?
4. This one I like, less comment bubbles, but still in a cool pattern.
5. I like the implied bubble, but a little thin for my tastes.
6. A pattern of 5s. Eh.
7. I like this one as well. The heads talking to each other.
So I like 4 & 7, and I'm leaning towards 7.
Second, #3 is the one. I like that it incorporates the "C" and "G" of Community Guy as well as keeps the talk-balloon meme that implies conversation and, thus, community.
#1 is a bit much methinks.
#2 makes me think of something photo-related.
#4 interesting but not enoughso
#5 makes me think something's missing.
#6 & #7 nice to look at but a little too abstract
So, it's #3, definitely. Nice meme that really markets YOU and what you're talking about.
My votes are for 4 and 6, with 1 being a close third... If I had to choose 1- it would be 6...